The Great Escape Hatch Has a Return Policy
Rosie O’Donnell, a failed Dutch asylum bid, and the Canadian housing reality check
There is a special kind of political theater that happens after an election: people announce that they are leaving the country, pack their moral superiority into a carry-on bag, and discover that the rest of the world has bills, borders, crime, paperwork, housing shortages and irritatingly complicated human beings too.
Donald Trump’s 2024 victory produced plenty of promises to flee. Some people actually moved. Rosie O’Donnell moved to Ireland after Trump won a second term. Transgender Americans sought relocation or asylum abroad. A TikTok creator calling herself Nope Brigade moved from Los Angeles to British Columbia and then explained that Canada’s housing crisis was worse than the one she had left behind.
Now the return traffic is becoming the story.
Not because America suddenly became perfect. It did not. Not because every criticism of the Trump administration is imaginary. It is not. And not because every person who left was a hypocrite. Some people were genuinely frightened, and some faced real policy changes that they believed threatened their families, work or safety.
Rosie O’Donnell discovers that family is still in New York
Rosie O’Donnell made the cleanest symbolic exit. After Trump’s re-election, she moved to Ireland with her child and described the move as a response to the political climate. On television, she discussed leaving after reading Project 2025 and Trump winning the election. She said Ireland had welcomed her, and there is no reason to doubt that.
But the return conversation started long before the 2026 midterms. In September 2025, O’Donnell said she was seeking advice about when it would be safe to return to America to see her older children. By February 2026, she had quietly spent two weeks in New York visiting family and testing how difficult it would be to enter and leave the country. She still said she did not regret leaving, but the return question was already on the table. After Democrats won both chambers in the 2026 midterms, the Washington Post reported that she was again thinking about moving back to New York, partly because she missed her grown children and grandson.
That is not a scandal. It is life. Family is not a partisan abstraction. A grandparent can love Ireland, dislike Trump and still decide that missing half a grandchild’s life is too high a price for making a political point.
The irony is that the people who treated her departure as proof that America was morally disqualified now want to treat the midterms as the moment that saved civilization. No. Her own timeline is messier: political fear, family, a trial visit, legal anxiety and changing circumstances were all part of the story.
It also proves that “I am leaving forever” is often the political version of “I am never speaking to you again.” Give it a few months, a visa problem or a family birthday. The human nervous system is not a campaign slogan.
The Netherlands was not the promised land
The most serious story is Jane-Michelle Arc, a transgender woman from California who sought asylum in the Netherlands after Trump administration policies made her fear for her future in the United States.
According to DutchNews, Arc was among approximately 76 Americans who sought asylum in the Netherlands the previous year. Her claim failed. She was sent to Ter Apel, a large asylum reception center, where she reported dire conditions and anti-trans hostility from other asylum seekers. She said she feared she could be hurt or killed and later returned to the United States.
Arc’s blunt assessment was devastatingly simple: “This is the dumbest thing I’ve ever done.”
That sentence deserves more respect than the usual partisan response. The right should not use one person’s terrible experience to pretend that transgender Americans have no legitimate concerns. The left should not use American policy concerns to pretend that every foreign asylum system is a safe, generous, well-run sanctuary. Both things can be true: Arc felt threatened by American policy, and the Dutch asylum center turned out to be more dangerous for her than the life she left.
The story is not that one government is pure and the other evil. The story is that institutions make promises, and vulnerable people pay the price when those promises meet capacity limits, crowded facilities, cultural conflict and bureaucratic indifference.
That is why slogans are a lousy substitute for policy. “Flee!” is not a resettlement plan. “Everything is fine!” is not a civil-rights policy. A free person deserves the right to choose where to live, but also deserves honest information before surrendering a job, a home, a support network or a workable legal status.
Canada’s housing crisis does not stop at the border
Then there is Nope Brigade, an academic researcher and TikTok creator who said she moved with her partner, a cat and a dog from Los Angeles to British Columbia after the election. She entered on a visitor visa, which meant she could not simply work locally. She said her savings were dwindling, health-care access was limited by her status, and the housing situation was worse than what she had experienced in Los Angeles.
Yahoo Finance reported her appeal for free or below-market housing and her description of the Canadian situation as “absolutely dire.” She specifically said she had lived in Los Angeles for six years without facing rent as bad as what she encountered in British Columbia.
That is not proof that every American is better off in Los Angeles. It is proof that geography does not repeal arithmetic. Moving to one of Canada’s most expensive housing markets on a visitor visa, without the right to work, is a high-risk personal decision.
And here is the important fact-checking distinction: the available reporting documents Brigade criticizing Canada’s costs. It does not document that she has already returned to the United States. So this article will not pretend that a complaint about rent is a confirmed repatriation. The lesson is still obvious: the promised escape hatch has a monthly rent attached to it.
The mass exodus was mostly a mass announcement
There were departures. There were also viral claims about celebrities who supposedly left America after Trump won. PolitiFact found that a widely circulated list naming Bruce Springsteen, Robert De Niro, Robert Downey Jr., John Legend and Tom Hanks was false. None of those celebrities had publicly announced that they were leaving.
The research is less theatrical. A study summarized by Phys.org found that most Americans who talked about leaving after the 2024 election stayed put. In one survey, more than 90 percent of respondents said they were not planning to leave for a lengthy period. After the election, seven people interviewed from the group all said they planned to stay.
That is the real story: America is not an airport departure board full of Democratic refugees. It is a country where people complain, threaten to move, price out real estate, call their friends, worry about their children and then discover that home is harder to abandon than a social-media post suggested.
Compared to what?
There is a Thomas Sowell question hiding underneath all of this: compared to what?
Compared to the United States, is Ireland more pleasant for some people? Certainly. Is Canada safer or more affordable for every American? Obviously not. Is the Netherlands automatically a better refuge for a transgender asylum seeker? Arc’s experience says no. Is America free of political danger, cultural hostility, expensive housing or government overreach? Absolutely not.
But every proposed escape requires a comparison. Compared to the life you actually have, not the life you imagine. Compared to your current rent, not a viral statistic. Compared to your family’s location, your visa status, your employment, your medical needs and your support network. Compared to the risks on both sides of the border.
The adult conclusion is not that America is perfect. Every country is a bundle of trade-offs, and pretending otherwise is how people end up in a refugee center, unable to work in a foreign housing market, or crying in Dublin because exile separated them from their grandchildren.
Welcome home—and read the fine print
If Rosie O’Donnell returns, welcome home. If Jane-Michelle Arc returns, welcome home. If Nope Brigade eventually decides that Vancouver is not worth the rent, welcome home. Americans do not lose their right to return because they made a dramatic exit. The country should be confident enough to let people come back without demanding a loyalty oath at the airport.
But perhaps the returnees can teach the rest of us something useful. Do not confuse a government with a country, a political promise with a workable plan, or a foreign postcard with a functioning life. Trump’s America has serious problems. So does every other country. The escape fantasy never included the return ticket.
Sources and evidence
- The Washington Post: Rosie O’Donnell considers a return to the United States after the 2026 midterms — supports O’Donnell’s move to Ireland, her stated self-exile, and her consideration of returning to New York after Democrats won both chambers.
- The Daily Beast: Rosie O’Donnell teases a return after the election — corroborates the post-midterm return discussion and the political context.
- The Daily Beast: O’Donnell sought advice about returning to America — documents the September 2025 return discussion, including her desire to see her older children safely.
- TheWrap: O’Donnell spent two weeks visiting family in the United States — documents her February 2026 trial visit to New York and confirms that the return question predated the midterms.
- ABC / Jimmy Kimmel Live: Rosie O’Donnell discusses moving to Ireland — primary media source for O’Donnell’s explanation of the move.
- DutchNews: U.S. transgender woman returns home after failed Dutch asylum bid — supports Jane-Michelle Arc’s asylum attempt, return, reported conditions at Ter Apel, and the approximate number of American applicants.
- The World / PRX: From San Francisco to a Dutch refugee camp — documents the broader reporting context around transgender Americans seeking asylum in Europe.
- Yahoo Finance: Political scholar who fled the U.S. says Canada’s cost of living is worse — supports the Nope Brigade account of moving to British Columbia, visitor-visa work limits, housing costs and the request for below-market housing.
- Phys.org: Despite claims they would move overseas, most Americans are staying put — supports the distinction between announced intentions and documented mass emigration.
- PolitiFact: False celebrity departure claims after the 2024 election — corrects viral claims about celebrities leaving the United States.
- Williams Institute: The Impact of Anti-Transgender Policy and Public Opinion on Travel and Relocation — provides survey context on transgender Americans considering relocation; it does not establish that all respondents moved abroad or returned.
Related Reading
Similar posts
2026-11-05 · Commentary
The Midterms Sent a Message: End the Iran War, Release the Epstein Files, and Stop Pretending Trump Kept His Promise
The 2026 midterms punished Trump’s war, high prices, and broken America First promises. Democrats now control Congress. Will they act—or perform?
Related · Commentary
I Don't Need My Children to Choose Me. I Want Them to Choose Themselves.
Ryan Thompson reflects on estrangement, parental love, personal responsibility, reconciliation, inheritance, and the freedom to let children choose their own lives.
2026-10-28 · Commentary